Welcome, visitor! [ Login ] 

 

comments are not permitted in json ?

  • Street: Zone Z
  • City: forum
  • State: Florida
  • Country: Afghanistan
  • Zip/Postal Code: Commune
  • Listed: 6 November 2022 9 h 36 min
  • Expires: This ad has expired

Description

comments are not permitted in json ?

### Comments are Not Permitted in JSON? Here’s How to Work Around It

#### The JSON Format: Designed for Data, Not Documentation

JSON, which stands for JavaScript Object Notation, is a data-interchange format that is language-independent, easy for humans to read and write, and easy for machines to parse and generate. It is primarily used for transmitting data from a server to a client.

However, one of the peculiarities of the JSON format is that it does not support comments. This can be a source of frustration for developers who are used to adding comments to their files for documentation purposes. So why is it that JSON does not allow comments? And what can you do if you still want to add comments to your JSON files?

### Understanding Why Comments are Not Allowed in JSON

Douglas Crockford, often credited with the creation or popularization of JSON (depending on your perspective), explains in his talk, *The JSON Saga*, that comments were initially supported in JSON. However, he later removed this feature for three main reasons:

1. **Consistency**: Ensuring that every JSON parser behaves in the same way was one of the core principles of the specification. Allowing comments would have led to inconsistencies because parsers would have had to handle them correctly, which was not always feasible or consistent across implementations.

2. **Simplicity**: JSON parsers are designed to be simple and efficient. Adding support for comments would complicated these parsers without added value for the JSON format itself, as comments are purely informational and do not contribute to the data being processed.

3. **Security**: Allowing comments could lead to code injection vulnerabilities if the comments were not properly handled. Imagine if a user could inject JavaScript code via comments in a JSON file that an application parses and executes.

### Configuring VS Code to Allow Comments in JSON Files

Despite the lack of support for comments in the JSON specification, many developers prefer the convenience of having comments in their configuration files. Fortunately, recent versions of Visual Studio Code (VS Code) support JSON with comments by using the `.jsonc` file extension or by changing the file association in VS Code manually.

#### Enabling JSON with Comments (JSONC) in VS Code

To enable JSON with comments in VS Code, follow these steps:

1. Open your JSON file in VS Code.
2. Switch the file type from JSON to JSON with Comments (JSONC).
– Click on the language indicator (usually `JSON`) in the bottom-right corner of the editor.
– Select the option “Configure File Association for ‘.json’…” from the drop-down menu.
– Type `jsonc` and press Enter.

Alternatively, you can configure JSONC for all JSON files by adding the following setting to your VS Code settings.json file:

“`json
“files.associations”: {
“*.json”: “jsonc”
}
“`

This change will allow you to use comments in your JSON files without causing validation errors in VS Code.

#### Why is JSONC supported?

The `.jsonc` file extension is recognized by VS Code and treats the file as JSON with comments. The JSONC format is essentially JSON with support for comments, making it easier for users to add documentation to their JSON files.

### Alternative Solutions: Preprocessors and Custom Parsers

If sticking with native JSON format is a requirement, other solutions include using preprocessors or custom parsers that can strip out comments before processing the JSON data.

– **Preprocessors**: You can use a preprocessor to remove comments from your JSON files before they are processed by your application. This way, you can maintain comments in your source files, while the applications only receive pure JSON.

– **Custom Parsers**: You can create a custom parser that supports comments. This might involve writing a small script that reads the JSON file, removes comments, and then parses the remaining JSON data.

### Final Thoughts

While JSON’s lack of support for comments can be a challenge, especially for those accustomed to using comments in other file formats, it follows the design philosophy of being simple and consistent. Fortunately, tools like Visual Studio Code offer workarounds like the JSONC format to accommodate the need for comments when editing configuration files.

Ultimately, the choice of whether to use JSON with comments (JSONC) or a different format often depends on the specific requirements and constraints of your project. If you need to maintain the pure JSON format, then using a preprocessor or custom parser might be your best option. If flexibility is more important, JSONC is a perfectly viable solution.

### References

– [Can comments be used in JSON? – Stack Overflow](https://stackoverflow.com/questions/244777/can-comments-be-used-in-json)
– [Why JSON doesn’t allow comments – Medium](https://medium.com/@marycriv/why-json-doesnt-allow-comments-fe93f7106c62)
– [Why are comments not allowed in JSON? | vorba.ch](https://vorba.ch/2013/json-comments.html)

Feel free to explore these resources for more in-depth discussions on this topic.

     

4 total views, 0 today

  

Listing ID: 5466367800a3e024

Report problem

Processing your request, Please wait....

Sponsored Links

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

↑