Description

который запятая ?

« Which Comma? »

When writing, one of the most common questions we ask ourselves is where to put punctuation marks. Today, we’re going to talk about a punctuation mark that is often overlooked, but is still very important: the comma. Specifically, we’re going to explore when to use a comma before the word « который ».

At first glance, it might seem obvious: before « который » we should always put a comma. However, the Russian language is complex and nuanced, and there are no absolute rules. In this article, we’ll delve into when to use a comma before « которий » and why.

The first thing to consider is the function of the word « которий » in the sentence. If it’s a coordinating conjunction, a comma is usually necessary. But if it’s a subordinating conjunction, a comma is not always necessary.

Let’s take a look at some examples. If we’re using « которий » in the sense of « who » or « which », a comma is usually necessary. For example: « We went to the forest, which is located behind the river ».

On the other hand, if « которий » is being used in the sense of « he who » or « that which », a comma is not necessary. For example: « We didn’t know which way to go ».

So, to summarize, a comma before « которий » is necessary when it’s being used as a coordinating conjunction, and not necessary when it’s being used as a subordinating conjunction.

It’s worth noting that some sources argue that a comma is always necessary before « которий », regardless of its function in the sentence. However, this is not universally agreed upon, and the best course of action is to consider the context and the function of the word in the sentence.

In conclusion, punctuation marks can be tricky, and there is no one-size-fits-all rule for using commas before the word « которий ». By understanding the function of the word in the sentence and considering the context, we can make informed decisions about where to put our commas.

Sources:

* [PishuGramotno.ru](https://PishuGramotno.ru/punktuacia/zapyataya-pered-kotoryj-pravila-punktuaczii)
* [RusskiiYazyk.ru](https://RusskiiYazyk.ru/punktuatsiya/kotoryy-zapyataya.html)
* [obrazovaka.ru](https://obrazovaka.ru/zapyataya/kotoryy.html)
* [yandex.ru/images/search](https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=который+запятая)
* [rrepetitor.ru](https://rrepetitor.ru/coma/kotoryj-znaki-prepinaniya/)
* [nauka.club](https://nauka.club/russkiy-yazyk/punktuatsiya/kotoryy.html)
* [rus.stackexchange.com](https://rus.stackexchange.com/questions/443567/Запятая-после-оборота-начинающегося-словом-который)
* [tvoy-vopros.ru](https://tvoy-vopros.ru/?p=222)
* [new.gramota.ru](https://new.gramota.ru/spravka/buro/search-answer?s=из которых)